Are Job Offer Letters Private and Confidential?

Are Job Offer Letters Private and Confidential?

Reviewed by: .

The job search process can be complex, especially when comparing offers from various companies. When you receive a better offer from one company, you may feel compelled to share this information with other hiring managers.

Job offer letters are not confidential — unless otherwise stated. You are under no legal obligation to keep your offer letter private. However, although there will be no legal repercussions, this may affect your potential job offers.

In the rest of this article, I will discuss the pros and cons of sharing your job offer letter with your current employer or other potential employers. 

Are There Any Legal Repercussions for Sharing the Details of a Job Offer?

Sharing a job offer letter with your current or potential employers opens up a dialogue that can potentially improve your job package. If you are tempted to share another company’s job offer letter, you shouldn’t worry about the legality of doing so.

There are no legal repercussions for sharing the details of a job offer letter. Therefore, you can share your offer letter with any employers without facing any consequences on the legal front.

You are under no binding contract to keep the details of your offer confidential unless stated otherwise. Typically, you will only find confidentiality necessary if you take up a confidential job, like working for the government. 

Otherwise, job offer letters are not and should not be confidential. As such, you are free to share the details with whomever you like.

Is It Ethical To Share a Job Offer Letter With My Current Employer?

Most people look for the best possible offer from a potential employer during the job search process. For instance, one typically asks for a higher salary, more benefits, and more time off. 

You will often find that some companies offer a better job package than what you currently have. When this is the case, you may be inclined to reveal your offer to your current employer.

It is perfectly ethical to share a job offer letter with your current employer. Sharing relevant details of your new offer gives them a choice to either pay you more or let you go.

As noted earlier, job offer letters are not confidential. Most prospective employers don’t require you to keep them a secret from your current employer or other potential employers. Therefore, this isn’t a question of ethics.

You don’t owe anything to the company that offered you a job. A job offer letter does not mean that you have officially started working for them. It is merely an offer that you may or may not take up. 

A job is a job – not a friend that you owe something to. You are on your own to find the best offer possible, and you should be sure to do everything you can to get the best for yourself. 

Are There Any Benefits to Disclosing Job Offers to the Employer and Others?

Disclosing job offers to your employer can be beneficial. Sharing an offer letter with your employers can help you negotiate better pay and benefits. If the competing position offers better benefits or pay, your employer may match that offer to keep you as an employee.

Think of job offer letters like you are negotiating a deal. Being open about the good deals you have with other parties will make it more likely for employers to up their offers to match or beat your current offer(s). 

If they want you to work for them, they will offer better terms. But how do you negotiate with a current employer when you have a competing offer?

Generally, it’s best to communicate with your employer openly and in a straightforward manner. Remember, most employers anticipate a conversation about payment rates and benefits. So, there’s no reason to feel fearful about bringing up increased pay or a better benefits package. 

At worst, the employer will reject those requests and maintain their initial payment and benefits. At best, you’ll score a far better offer that pays more and offers more benefits! 

Without further ado, let’s discuss how you can approach a discussion about competing job offers with your current employer. 

Open Dialogue Is a Good Thing

Salary negotiation is a natural part of the hiring process. Companies fully expect you to negotiate your salary and to try to get the best possible offer. 

Open dialogue works best for both you and your employer. When you alert a company to a better offer you have received, they can best determine if it suits their budget and needs to increase or lower their offer. 

Sometimes, hiring managers will inquire about your other offers because of this. They want to know if they can match the salary that you will receive at the other company. If they aren’t, they will let you know, ensuring that your time isn’t wasted. 

It’s also unlikely that you would accept a low offer unless you are passionate about that particular position. More often than not, better pay and benefits win the day. 

If your current or prospective employer can increase your pay and improve your benefits, you’ll be glad you discussed competing job offers.

Remember, the job search process is about negotiating and arriving at an agreement that works for both of you. You will probably not be sticking around for long if you are underpaid, anyway. 

For that reason, you’ll also want to be straightforward about your objective when discussing competing job offers.

Be Straightforward With Your Objectives

The best thing you can do in the job search process is be straightforward with the hiring managers. For example, you should tell them if you want a higher salary. 

If you got a better offer somewhere else, let them know!

Being straightforward and honest allows both parties to reach an agreement more quickly and efficiently. At the end of the negotiations, you’re both more likely to be satisfied with the outcome.

If you’re not accustomed to being assertive in these situations, you may want to practice the conversation before approaching your current or prospective employer.

Practice the Discussion Beforehand

It’s normal to feel nervous before discussing competing job offers with a current or prospective employer. After all, the potential outcome could change your standard of living for the better.

However, it’s crucial to go into this type of conversation confidently and calmly. Therefore, calming your nerves is vital.

One of the best ways to keep calm and maintain an air of confidence is to practice your discussion beforehand. You can do this in front of a mirror or any private space. 

To start, write down the key points you’d like to make during your discussion. After you’ve finished, read those key points aloud.

Go through this practice conversation as many times as you need. Doing so will help you approach the job offer discussion more confidently, potentially increasing your chances of securing higher pay or better benefits.

Could I Not Be Hired for Sharing a Job Offer With Other Employers?

It is quite rare that one company will alert another company regarding what you have told them. It’s even rarer that a company will revoke its offer because of your input or comments.

The company will not fail to hire you for sharing your job offer letter with other employers. Doing so will most likely not affect the hiring process. The primary reason a company may not hire you is if they cannot pay you enough to match the other salary.

If this is the case, not being hired shouldn’t matter. You will most likely not accept an offer that pays you less, anyway. 

Therefore, there are no real drawbacks to sharing your offer letters. 

Pro Tip: You Can Keep the Prospective Employer’s Name Anonymous When Sharing Your Job Offer

When discussing competing job offers, you may prefer to keep the rival company’s name anonymous. In most cases, doing so will not impact your ability to haggle for better pay or benefits from your current or other prospective employers.

The only exception to this would be highly reputable or exceptionally powerful companies. 

For example, if you have three job offers but one is from an internationally-recognized company with a near-perfect reputation, you may choose not to keep that company anonymous when discussing job offers.

Still, if you’d like to protect the identity of your prospective employers, you can digitally or physically censor their names and information before discussing competing job offers. The best way to do this varies depending on whether you’ve received a physical or digital copy of the offer.

If you’re working with a digitalized job offer (i.e., a .pdf or .doc file), you’ll first want to make a copy of that document. 

After that, you can access the copy and either delete the company’s information or censor it using the highlight tool (for .doc files) and choose black as your preferred highlight color. If you’re working with a .pdf file, you can censor information using the ‘Redact’ tool.

Conclusion

Sharing your job offer letters with your current or future employer has no legal repercussions. Job offer letters are not confidential and don’t require you to keep them a secret. 

In fact, some hiring managers expect you to use other offers to negotiate your salary and will sometimes even inquire about those offers. 

Therefore, you should use your job offer letter to get the best salary possible and all the benefits you deserve. 

Sources